Pizza Guys Reviews

I’ll be honest, I’m a little biased because I really do like their pizza, especially when it shows up hot. Most of the time the food is solid, but the delivery timing is kind of unpredictable. Some days it gets here surprisingly fast, and other days it’s 20–30 minutes late with no update, which is frustrating. Not a dealbreaker for me, but I definitely don’t order from here when I’m in a rush

I don’t get why anyone would complain about the menu being limited. There were tons of choices, and even my picky kids managed to find something they actually liked, which pretty much never happens

I’ve ordered from pizzaguys.com a few times now, i keep coming back because I really like the flavor. To me, the cheese tastes fresh, the sauce has just enough of a little kick, and the crust actually has some flavor instead of being plain and forgettable. The pepperoni has been my favorite so far. It’s not trying to be super fancy or anything — it’s just really good pizza that hits the spot for me.

I ordered from pizzaguys.com for pickup recently because I figured it would be quick and easy, but this last experience kind of put me off. The site gave me a pickup time, and when I got there, my order still wasn’t ready. The staff seemed confused trying to find it, and I ended up just standing around without anyone really updating me. The pizza itself was fine, but the whole point of ordering online was convenience. After this visit, I’m not sure I’d bother doing pickup again anytime soon

The pizza was okay, nothing really amazing, but the floor and tables looked dirty. It really kind of put me off eating there, to be honest

My order showed up really quick, and the driver was super polite. Best part was the pizza was still HOT when it got here, which I really appreciated

I was so happy with how quickly my pizza showed up today. It got here way faster than I expected, and that made the whole experience even better!

I’ve ordered from Pizza Guys a bunch of times now, and it’s been consistent each visit. The pizza shows up hot, the order is right, and there haven’t been any weird surprises. The one time I had a quick question, support basically said something like, “No problem, we’ll make sure it’s taken care of,” which was nice and easy. Nothing flashy, just reliable pizza. Can’t really complain.

This place is right near my work, so for me it’s one of those super easy spots to swing by when I’m craving pizza. I like that I don’t have to go out of my way at all, which makes it a convenient option during a busy day.

I ordered pizza, but I’m telling you right now, the dessert completely stole the show. The cinnamon treats were warm, soft, and somehow perfectly sweet without being over the top. Not dry at all, which is basically a miracle compared to some other places. I would 100% order again just for those, no question.

I ordered from Pizza Guys last night and had a really good experience. The guy on the phone was patient and didn’t make me feel rushed while I asked about different toppings and deals. When I went to pick up the order, the staff were all friendly and welcoming, which makes a big difference. The pizza was good, but the service is what really stood out to me and it’s definitely why I’d order from them again.

Everything I ordered showed up correctly, so I can’t really complain too much. I just kind of wish the sauces had been labeled better because I had to guess which was which for a minute

The store was clean enough, but it felt plain inside. I went in expecting maybe a nicer sit-down vibe, but it’s more like a quick grab-and-go spot. The staff was fine, no real complaints there, but the atmosphere just wasn’t doing much for me. Kind of left feeling like I should’ve chosen a different place

I order from Pizza Guys often, mostly because the cheese is the best part. It tastes fresh, melts really well, and they don’t skimp on it like a lot of other places do. Even when I get delivery, it still has that nice stretchy cheese thing going on, which I love. The pizza itself is simple, but it usually hits the spot. That said, the last time I had a small issue with my order, I felt kind of dismissed when I brought it up, which was disappointing since I’ve been a regular customer.

I ordered from pizzaguys and, not gonna lie, I was a little worried I’d get fooled by nice pictures and end up with barely any toppings. But I was surprised. Every slice had a solid amount on it, not just a random few pieces scattered around. It actually felt like I got what I paid for, which doesn’t always happen with pizza places. I’d definitely order again

I’m just relieved this didn’t turn into one of those checkout nightmares where you’re suddenly fighting error messages, re-entering your card three times, or wondering if the payment even went through. I paid quickly, everything worked like it was supposed to, and there were no weird surprises. Why can’t every checkout be this simple?

I ordered from pizzaguys.com and overall the pizza was just okay. The crust was fine and the toppings were decent, but the sauce really threw it off for me. It tasted too sweet and had a weird aftertaste that I couldn’t get past. I can see some people liking it if they prefer sweeter sauce, but for customers who like a more traditional pizza flavor, it might be a miss.

Ordering was quick and everything went through without any issues. To be fair, I didn’t need anything complicated, but for a simple order, it was smooth and hassle-free.

Ordered from pizzaguys last night, the crust was the best part. I’m always complaining about pizza crust being too dry, too hard, or just plain boring, and I complain about leaving the edges almost every time. But this one actually had a nice crisp outside while still being soft and chewy inside. I usually never eat the crust, seriously, I almost always leave it, but I ate the whole thing this time. It tasted fresh, held up with the toppings, and didn’t get weird or soggy. No complaints here for once. Easy 5 stars from me.

I grabbed some wings from Pizza Guys the other night, mostly just as a side, and they ended up being better than I expected. They were crispy on the outside but still juicy inside, which is always the thing I hope for with wings but don’t always get. The sauce was good too, not like dripping everywhere or making the whole box a mess. I got buffalo and BBQ, and both had solid flavor. I was kind of thinking they might just be whatever, but no, I’d definitely order them again. Maybe even before the pizza next time, which feels weird to say, but here we are...